Pope Francis & SSPX: Reconciliation Steps & Marriage Validity - Latest
Is reconciliation between the Vatican and the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) truly within reach, or are the divisions too deep to bridge? Despite ongoing efforts, a complex web of theological disagreements and canonical challenges continues to complicate the path towards full communion.
The relationship between the Vatican and the SSPX, a traditionalist Catholic priestly society, has been a source of ongoing discussion and debate for decades. Founded in 1970 by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, the SSPX has consistently opposed many of the reforms of the Second Vatican Council, particularly those related to liturgical changes, ecumenism, and religious freedom. This stance has led to a state of canonical irregularity, with the SSPX operating outside of the formal structures of the Catholic Church. While the Vatican has expressed a desire for reconciliation, significant hurdles remain.
Pope Francis has continued initiatives aimed at a reconciliation with the priestly society of St. Pius X, he has made it possible for bishops to ensure the validity of marriages celebrated within the society. However, this is not a simple issue.
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) | A traditionalist Catholic priestly society founded by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in 1970. Known for its adherence to traditional Latin Mass and opposition to certain Vatican II reforms. |
| Founder | Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre |
| Key Beliefs | Strict adherence to pre-Vatican II teachings, traditional Latin Mass, rejection of certain Vatican II reforms. |
| Canonical Status | In a state of canonical irregularity. Excommunicated in 1988, although efforts towards reconciliation have been ongoing. |
| Relationship with the Vatican | Marked by both dialogue and disagreement. Pope Francis has taken steps to facilitate reconciliation, but significant doctrinal differences remain. |
| Current Leadership | Superior General Don Davide Pagliarani |
| Activities | Celebration of traditional Latin Mass, operation of seminaries and schools, publishing of theological and apologetical material. |
| Key Criticisms | Seen as schismatic by some within the Catholic Church. Concerns about their rejection of Vatican II teachings and authority of the Pope. |
| Web Link for Reference | Official Website of the Society of Saint Pius X |
All the popes from Paul VI to Francis (except John Paul I, who died early in his pontificate) have, at different times, cautioned against attending SSPX chapels, citing the society's schismatic status. Pope Francis himself has stated that the SSPX is in schism, echoing the long-standing concerns of church leaders who have, at times, expressed the same. This creates confusion, as there are also measures being taken to acknowledge their priestly ministry.
The Vatican's liturgy chief recently noted that Pope Francis issued Traditionis Custodes, a document restricting the celebration of the traditional Latin Mass, partially due to the perceived failure of efforts to reconcile with the SSPX. The Vatican has stated that it is necessary to "go back" to the spirit of Vatican II.
In Vatican City, Pope Francis's decision to approve a way for the Church to recognize marriages celebrated by priests of the SSPX is a helpful step toward the restoration of full communion, through a letter published April 4th, the pope has given diocesan bishops or other local ordinaries the authorization to grant priests of the SSPX the ability to licitly and validly celebrate. This step, while seemingly a gesture of goodwill, is balanced with the broader restrictions on the traditional Latin Mass, which have been seen by some as a sign of caution and of an unwillingness to compromise on the doctrinal matters which form the bedrock of the Church.
On Tuesday, February 8, 2022, Don Davide Pagliarani, Superior General of the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX), traveled to Rome, where he had a private audience with Pope Francis for approximately half an hour. The purpose of this meeting has not been fully disclosed, but it undoubtedly involved discussions regarding the ongoing dialogue and possible pathways toward canonical reconciliation. This meeting shows an important commitment on the part of both parties to keep communication open and to continue to search for ways to address the difficulties that have divided them. A personal meeting like this between the Pope and the head of the SSPX demonstrates the significance of the relationship.
Both the Vatican and the SSPX have confirmed that Pope Francis met with Bishop Bernard Fellay, the priestly society's superior general, at the Vatican. This meeting signals a concerted effort to mend divides and find common ground, but is in stark contrast with the ongoing restrictions put in place by the Vatican in relation to the Traditional Latin Mass.
On April 4, 2017, the Vatican published a document dated March 27 concerning marriages celebrated by the priests of the SSPX. At the instruction of Pope Francis, Cardinal Gerhard Mller, the prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and Archbishop Guido Pozzo, secretary of the Ecclesia Dei, oversaw the issuance of the document. This directive clarified the canonical status of marriages performed by SSPX priests and was intended to facilitate a more regular relationship between the society and the Catholic Church. The move showed a willingness by the Vatican to provide pastoral support to those who frequent SSPX chapels.
In a significant development, a sympathetic Cardinal Daro Castrilln Hoyos, president of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, approached the SSPX bishops during a pilgrimage. According to Bishop Fellay, Cardinal Hoyos indicated that the Pope was prepared to grant the SSPX either a personal prelature (a juridical structure used by Opus Dei), or an apostolic administration. This was a considerable offer, and one that demonstrated that the Vatican wished to address the SSPX's canonical concerns, but at the same time, retain control over the movement.
Under Pope Francis, Rome has taken measures to bring the SSPX closer to a regularized canonical situation. This can be seen through a variety of actions, the pope is also taking a position of caution when dealing with the SSPX. While SSPX masses have always been seen, the official stance of the Church has not been universally supportive of the SSPX and there are ongoing concerns of schism.
It is essential to consider why accusations of schism are leveled against the SSPX, considering Pope Francis's interventions, such as his contact with the Argentinian government. The SSPX recognizes the validity of all legitimate popes, including Pope John Paul II, under whom its founder, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, and the four bishops he unlawfully ordained were excommunicated in 1988. The Society's position is complex: it acknowledges the papacy while questioning certain teachings and reforms.
The most recent initiatives, such as the September 2015 announcement by Pope Francis that the faithful could validly and licitly receive absolution from SSPX priests, show a deliberate attempt to address the pastoral needs of Catholics who attend SSPX chapels. This decision offered a pathway for absolution, despite the SSPX's irregular canonical status. This could be seen as a step toward reconciliation.
Further complicating the landscape is the role of individuals who have engaged in the dialogue between the Vatican and the SSPX. These people are often involved in the discussion of both canonical and theological issues. For example, in discussions with the Holy See, he is a consultant to the SSPX commission responsible for doctrinal discussions.
The choice of leadership within the SSPX has shifted over time, with new leaders emerging who are believed to be more open to fostering better relations with Pope Francis. It is essential to note that the push toward reconciliation is not without internal opposition, and that pursuit of this policy requires rejecting what some would see as an open letter which contains a harsh critique of the process.
The private meeting between Pope Francis and Father Andrzej Komorowski followed a request from the Fraternity of Saint Peter (FSSP), a priestly society in full communion with the Vatican. This meeting underscores the importance of the pastoral care of traditionalist communities within the Church, but also the nuanced relationship between the Vatican and these different groups. The FSSP has, for the time being, avoided many of the problems encountered by the SSPX.
Pope Francis's apostolic letter Misericordia et Misera granted the faculty to validly and licitly absolve sins to SSPX priests. However, this was a limited measure, and other faculties were not extended. The specific focus on absolution shows a prioritization of the spiritual well-being of the faithful over a comprehensive canonical integration.
Theological debates continue to surface. The SSPX maintains a distinct theological stance. The theological positions of the SSPX are often at odds with mainstream Catholic thought. The use of terms like "heretical" is now regarded as less constructive within the Church. The core of their theological opposition centres on their interpretation of Vatican II and its impact on Catholic doctrine and practice. The ongoing theological debates are at the heart of the difficulties in achieving full communion.
On June 8, 2017, an article appeared entitled, "Unity of Faith with Pope Francis & Canonical Recognition of the SSPX," which explored the complexities of this relationship. The complexities underscore the need for dialogue to find common ground. The communication of an episcopal power of jurisdiction carried out contrary to the Pope's will would be thus purely and simply invalid, whereas the communication of an episcopal power of order, also carried out contrary to the pope's will, would indeed be gravely illicit, but perfectly valid.
 truly within reach, or are the divisions too deep to bridge? Despite ongoing effort){kind=link}